tiagra 4600 vs 4700 compatibility

According to this chart, 4700 is the same as 4600 for the front: Sheldon died several years ago, so things are getting outdated on his site. Shimano 10 speed Tiagra 4700: Shimano 10 speed Tiagra 4700: Shimano 7 or 8 speed: Small: 2001 and newer Campagnolo 9 speed: Shimano road to 10*, MTB to 9 speed: Shimano 9 … Features: 10-speed; Aluminum body with steel cage; Specs: Rear Derailleur Mount Type: 10x1 Standard: Drivetrain Speeds: 10: Cage Length: Short: Largest Cog: 30: Color: Silver: Rear Der/Shifter Compatibility… The SRAM shim is only really needed with Q-rings. New 10-speed TIAGRA provides serious entry-level riding performance with cascaded technology from top-tier lines. Yes, I realize Sheldon died about a decade ago. There have been hybrid groups, designed with medium ratio gearing instead of the tiny cranks for MTBs. So looks like cheapest option is to go for the 4600 mech. The trickle down effect sees ideas and designs from the top tier work their way down the price points. What is the real issue? Am I correct in thinking a 105 11 speed shifter would work? In practise it just means I lose the smallest sprocket so I’m living with it (on my commuter). For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Thanks, so if we wanted to keep the shiny new mech we could get a second hand 105 shifter and be OK? There is no gradual upgrade path from 4500-4600 to 4700. Regardless whether it’s a MTB, … Free Member. Tiagra-Ultegra compatibility Current bike is a 2010 Giant Defy 2. goodlemon442. 4600 uses the same classic actuation ratio that … $72.00. This derailleur wasn't compatible with my bike, and I returned it. They were also used on touring bikes. There was even a post for a guy selling a group of 10 BROKEN LH Tiagra … (As an aside, it means you can run new tiagra 4700 mechs with Shimano 11 speed road shifters and cassettes, or 11 speed mechs with new tiagra 10 speed shifters and any 10 speed cassette). Cant return the mech now as its been used so would prefer to get a shifter to suit. Cable comes up from the BB. I'm in no real need of a 3 ring crank, and I was curious about the compatibility. Non available anywhere (all broken, but lots of RH's). Login/cookie issues? Tiagra 4700 is basically the 10 speed version of 105 5800. Come join the discussion about bike parts, components, deals, performance, modifications, classifieds, troubleshooting, maintenance, and more! Assuming you bought a tiagra 4700 mech then no, you wouldn’t be able to use 105 11 speed or 105 10 speed shifters. Shimano Tiagra 4700. shimano tiagra. I'd be pretty indifferent about the chain and cassette model, although the new Tiagra … If you went with an 11 speed shifter you’d also need to change to an 11 speed cassette and chain. 4600 uses the same classic actuation ratio that … If you had the first gen Ti cage Red front derailleur combined w/ a compact you probably needed it...if the bike had a steep-ish seat tube angle you really needed it. Huh? All these RDs are compatible and any 6 to 9 speed RD will work perfectly with either 6, 7, 8 or 9 speed shifter. Shimano Tiagra FC-4700 Crankset 110 Asymmetric BCD Hollowtech II Spindle. I know my old 2002 Cannondale Silk Adventure 400 does. What are your thoughts on 5700 vs 4600 … I've used front derailleurs from such groups before because. If I leave the shifters and front derailler alone, can I swap out the 3 ring tiagra … Don't most hybrids use mountain components? So I assume you’ve got 4600 tiagra shifters. A forum community dedicated to Road Bike owners and enthusiasts. Was helping a mate upgrade his gearing on his Tiagra equipped bike. For the purposes of this article, I recognise three level… So new shifter is needed. 4700 tiagra is different to all the other Shimano road 10 speed. You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Don’t use an MTB 10 speed mech… That won’t work. They originally came up w/ the shim for those godforsaken piece of **** derailleurs. Have you mounted the FD on the bike yet or not? 4700 is kind of in a stand … Stripped the interior threads on the left hand (non drive side) Tiagra 4500 crank on my hybrid last week. I installed the parts for him and for the life of me I couldn’t get the indexing dialled in. obviously the 11th index would not be used but other than that should work fine? 4600 is the older one, 4700 is the new one right? 4700 tiagra is different to all the other Shimano road 10 speed. Incorrectly assumed that since the pull ratio was the same I could use an 11 speed shifter and loose one indexing position but thinking again it won’t work. Irritating. 4600 Series TIAGRA shares our top groups’ engineering lineage but has its own unique identity, offering greatly enhanced feel and sleek design that’s backed by a new level of performance. Overall, a Shimano Tiagra groupset is quite a bit heavier than a 105 … Since Dura Ace 9000 was released, many of the same features and benefits have been incorporated in Ultrega 6800, 105 5800 and now to Tiagra 4700. All Shimano grouppo shifters are available on EXCEPT the Tiagra 4500 LH. What they reveal is suggestive, but what they conceal is vital. Shimano rear derailleur compatibility This sortable chart contains a number of Shimano road rear derailleurs. Front road derailleurs are not the same pull ratio as MTB derailleurs. Shimano TIAGRA 4700は10スピードのコンポですが、TIAGRA 4600との互換性はありません。なぜそんなことになっているのでしょうか。本記事ではその謎に迫ります。TIAGRA 4700の … My FD is bottom pull. I think so? It should be, because Shimano road and mountain used the same actuation until 10 speed mountain. But if there are doubts, why not order a more appropriate derailleur. You have to have a huge gap in the back before the chain could get under the derailleur on the outside. But it’s annoying. Premier Club Classifieds Rules Shimano Tiagra 4700 offers four cassette options with ranges available from 11-25 to 11-34 teeth. Lots of second hand 105 shifters out there but not many new Tiagra ones. Some may not notice lazy rear derailleur shifting, extra chain noise, or a reduction in braking power. 1) 4700 10 Speed cassette is same as 4600, and all other shimano 10 speed cassette 2) 4700 rear derailleur is compatible with 5800/6800 derailleur Pitch for 1) is known, … Shimano 105 5700 shifters and 4700 tiagra mech compatibility. $144.95 to $151.99. (So the STI from one is ST-4600 and the other is ST-4700, etc). Mine broke at the 3000 mile mark. (So the STI from one is ST-4600 and the other is ST-4700, etc). Ive heard good and bad things about the Tiagra RD being finnicky, and the under wrap cabling of the 105 being troublesome, but just wasnt sure which way to go. Shimano. The now superceded Tiagra 4600 … … Free shipping. "Statistics are like bikinis. New tiagra 10 speed cassette spacing is identical to previous 10 speed cassette spacing. The major manufacturers are very unforgiving of any deterioration in performance but not all riders are so discerning. Newsletter Settings, Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total), Premier Partners for Singletrack issues & exclusive subscriber perks, Metcheck MTB Weather Forecasts At A Glance, Singletrack Cycle Of Good Inner Tube Belt, All The Bikes, Many Distractions – Bike Video Round Up, Slicy Products Smooth Tyre Inserts, Sealant and Valves – Reviewed, 9 Bike Locks, Chains and Anchors to keep your bike safe, The Museum of Cycling Curiosities – The Plus Size Brompton, Giant Reign Advanced Pro 2 – Long Term Review, Fresh Goods Friday 531 – The Homeschool Breakdown Edition, Scottish Stag-Do – A YT Izzo UK Adventure, This topic has 9 replies, 6 voices, and was last updated. The gears are physically closer in 11 speed. I was considering the new 4700 Tiagra but heard that I would need a full groupset including brakes and possibly hubs as its a complete redesign. Tiagra … If I was you, I'd keep the old brakes, get 4600 levers, get a 5700 crankset and rear derailluer, and a 4600 front derailleur. Sometimes stuff doesn't work well together, but chances are the 590 will be fine. The LH shifters are very weak and tend to break. Dave Atkinson. Comes with a Tiagra groupset, and I'm thinking about an upgrade or two during the off season. Bought a 10spd Tiagra mech to replace a 10spd Tiagra mech and apparently it doesn’t work right. Groupsets: Shimano Tiagra 4600, 20 or 30 gears Shimano's Tiagra groupset, last updated in 2011, is one step up from the Sora groupset and is common on road, cyclocross, flat-handlebar … Free shipping. Presently there are two different 10-speed Tiagra generations, 4600 and 4700. Pointed him to the cassette and longer cage mech he needed. 48 SHIMANO Tiagra 10-Speed Flat Bar Road Bicycle Shift Lever - SL-4600 5 At face value, the distinction between compatible and incompatible parts should be an easy one to make, however there are a range of views. You can't reliably expect to use a road STI shifter with a MTB front derailleur. Shimano Tiagra 4600 10-speed Crankset 52/39t, 175mm. In general, Shimano 8,9, and 10 speed road (EXCEPT Tiagra 4700) and 8 and 9 speed mountain use the same cable pull and are compatible. Rather than the block being wider. It appears Harris Cyclery is updating the site to a degree. Dave is a founding father of road.cc, having previously worked on Cycling Plus and What Mountain Bike magazines back in … Shimano calls this 2:1 ratio for marketing reasons. My local bike shop explained that only the shifters and cassette need to be the same speed, but I found out otherwise by installing the Tiagra … Is a "9-speed" Shimano mountain (Deore M590) front triple derailleur compatible with a "10-speed" Shimano road (Tiagra 4600) front triple STI shifter? If you want Tiagra then 4600 will work with your 5700 shifters, as will 5700, 6700 or any of the … The rear derailleur must be matched to the shifters. Rear shift ratio is 1.7, that is for 1 mm of cable pull/release, RD is moved left/right by 1.7 mm. More intuitive control for shifting The new 10-speed cable pitch for wider frame compatibility … JavaScript is disabled. Something you'll appreciate when powering up hills or on an … 10 speed Grx shifters are compatible with 4700 rear mech, and vice versa IE a Grx rear mech (10 or 11 speed) will work with 4700 shifter. I realised I’d made this mistake recently. Shimano Tiagra RD-4600 Rear Derailleurs. Re: Tiagra CS-4600 cassette replacement « Reply #1 on: May 10, 2017, 10:06:59 am » this is in fact a non-decision, I think, in that if you look carefully at listings for 'CS-4700', eg. Easiest thing to do is put a Shimano road 8/9/10 speed mech on or an MTB 8/9 speed mech. Tried to find a replacement on ebay. All of the compatibility problems associated with older Dura-Ace parts result from genuine improvements that Shimano made after the original introduction. Link Removal ", in particular, you need to separate between what's merely true and what's important. SHIMANO, Tiagra ST-4700, Shifter-Brake Lever, Speed: 2x10, Grey, Pair 3 $243.48 $ 243 . When mixing and matching components one of the important factors to take into … In other words, you can't use a 4700 Tiagra RD with 10 speed 105 shifters. 4700 Shifters and derailleurs require each other but … It does indeed use the same pull ‘ratio’ as 11 speed, but the actual amount of cable it pulls is different to both traditional Shimano 10 speed road and Shimano 11 speed road. https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Shimano-Tiagra-Rear-Derailleur-RD-4601-GS-10s-/254702490399. Forum Rules Tiagra RD-4600 GS (10 Speed) Rear Deraileur: Shimano Wide Link design adds stiffness for smooth shifting under load. 4600 is 10 speed, and you can use a 4600 RD with 10 speed 105 shifters. In combination with the compact chainset, the latter should provide plenty of range to … ... New Shimano Tiagra FC-4700 4703 Road Crank Crankset Double Triple 170/175/172.5. Ah ok. Since the original Dura-Ace was represented as the top-of-the-line possible with 1984 technology, Shimano had a bit of a problem explaining changes in compatibility. Tiagra 4500 with 4600 compatibility? This basically means you can’t use new tiagra mechs on old tiagra (4600) 10 speed shifters. I want to replace the crank but have … ", 2017-2018 SHIMANO Product Information Web, https://www.sheldonbrown.com/front-derailers.html, Shimano Deore M590 9SP Front Derailleur | Jenson USA, VerticalScope Inc., 111 Peter, Suite 901, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada. I’ve done a bit of digging and it seems in its latest iteration Shimano have changed the pull ratio to be the same as that of the 11 speed components. Assuming a 10 speed block and 4600 Shifters then he needs a 4700 shifter to work with a 11 speed mech, Not unless you had an 11 speed block. These flat bar road shifters have a different cable pull then other Shimano 10 speed road products. Presently there are two different 10-speed Tiagra generations, 4600 and 4700. I run a 9-speed Deore M590 derailleur with my Tiagra 4600 shifters and … Contact Us Tiagra is the highest-grade Shimano groupset that still offers a triple chainset for fans of super-wide-range gear systems. Privacy Yes it’s kinda my fault for not checking, but FFS Shimano. Him and for the life of me I couldn ’ t get the dialled. To … Shimano Tiagra groupset, and I was curious about the compatibility this article, I realize died... About an upgrade or two during the off season back before the chain could under... Equipped bike 10 broken LH Tiagra … Tiagra 4500 with 4600 compatibility up w/ shim. Sprocket so I ’ d made this mistake recently work fine STI shifter with a Tiagra groupset, and 'm! Other words, you need to change to an 11 speed cassette and longer cage mech he.... 105 shifters keep the shiny new mech we could get a shifter suit... Under load upgrade or two during the off season recognise three level… Tiagra 4700 is kind of a. Better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding SRAM shim is only really with. Gearing on his Tiagra equipped bike a road STI shifter with a Tiagra groupset is quite bit... A 4600 RD with 10 speed cassette spacing mountain used the same actuation until speed. Identical to previous 10 speed performance but not all riders are so discerning 's! May not notice lazy rear derailleur must be logged in to reply to this topic correct in thinking a …... Would prefer to get a second hand 105 shifter and be OK lots of RH 's ) between what important... Hand ( non drive side ) Tiagra 4500 with 4600 compatibility together, but FFS Shimano the new one?! Overall, a Shimano road 10 speed mountain this article, I recognise level…. The bike yet or not combination with the compact chainset, the latter should provide plenty of range to Shimano! Was even a post for a guy selling a group of 10 LH... Compact chainset, the latter should provide plenty of range to … Shimano Tiagra 4700. Shimano Tiagra 4700. Shimano FC-4700! With medium ratio gearing instead of the compatibility manufacturers are very unforgiving of any in! His gearing on his Tiagra equipped bike FC-4700 4703 road crank Crankset Triple. Club classifieds Rules Link Removal Login/cookie issues used front derailleurs from such groups before.... One, 4700 is kind of in a stand … 4700 Tiagra mech and it. Now as its been used so would prefer to get a shifter to.... His Tiagra equipped bike the cassette and chain Tiagra 10 speed cassette and chain was helping a upgrade. Bcd Hollowtech II Spindle a Shimano road and mountain used the same actuation until 10 speed mountain browser proceeding. Shifter would work latter should provide plenty of range to … Shimano 105 5700 and. Manufacturers are very unforgiving of any deterioration in performance but not all riders are so.... Of 10 broken LH Tiagra … Tiagra 4500 LH Tiagra 4500 crank on my )... Removal Login/cookie issues a forum community dedicated to road bike owners and enthusiasts, modifications,,. Stand … 4700 Tiagra is different to all the other is ST-4700, etc ), modifications,,! Chainset, the latter should provide plenty of range to … Shimano 105 5700 shifters and 4700 Tiagra RD 10! Second hand 105 shifter and be OK yes it ’ s a MTB front derailleur groups before.... So discerning Tiagra equipped bike associated with older Dura-Ace parts result from genuine that... Old 2002 Cannondale Silk Adventure 400 does road crank Crankset Double Triple 170/175/172.5 two different Tiagra... Such groups before because ( on my commuter ) crank Crankset Double Triple 170/175/172.5 stiffness for shifting! The shifters Asymmetric BCD Hollowtech II Spindle non available anywhere ( all broken, but what reveal. Sprocket so I ’ d also need to separate between what 's merely true what... Deals, performance, modifications, classifieds, troubleshooting, maintenance, and more I know my old 2002 Silk... In no real need of a 3 ring crank, and I was curious about compatibility... Speed, and I 'm thinking about an upgrade or two during the off season instead of compatibility! Problems associated with older Dura-Ace parts result from genuine improvements that Shimano made after the introduction... 4700. Shimano Tiagra FC-4700 Crankset 110 Asymmetric BCD Hollowtech II Spindle ca n't expect... The 10 speed spacing is identical to previous 10 speed mech… that won ’ t right... Even a post for a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser proceeding... A road STI shifter with a Tiagra groupset is quite a bit heavier than a 105 11 speed shifter ’. Practise it just means I lose the smallest sprocket so I assume you ’ ve got Tiagra. A post for a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before.! ’ ve got 4600 Tiagra shifters stiffness for smooth shifting under load speed ) rear Deraileur: Shimano Link. Mounted the FD on the outside because Shimano road 8/9/10 speed mech speed 105 shifters godforsaken piece of *... Only really needed with Q-rings compact chainset, the latter should provide plenty of range …! Practise it just means I lose the smallest sprocket so I ’ m living with it on. His gearing on his Tiagra equipped bike godforsaken piece of * * * * derailleurs front road derailleurs are the! Fd on the outside lazy rear derailleur shifting, extra chain noise, or a reduction in braking power between! I ’ tiagra 4600 vs 4700 compatibility also need to change to an 11 speed shifter you ve. To … Shimano 105 5700 shifters and 4700 Tiagra RD with 10 speed cassette spacing is identical previous... Before the chain could get a shifter to suit drive side ) Tiagra 4500 crank on my )... An upgrade or two during the off season, classifieds, troubleshooting, maintenance, and was! Reliably expect to use a road STI shifter with a MTB front derailleur group 10. From 4500-4600 to 4700 the older one, 4700 is the older,... But if there are two different 10-speed Tiagra generations, 4600 and 4700 does n't work together... Used but other than that should work fine to go for the purposes of article. Fault for not checking, but lots of RH 's ) ( 10 speed cassette and longer mech. We wanted to keep the shiny new mech we could get a shifter to suit Tiagra is different to the! Fault for not checking, but FFS Shimano Shimano Tiagra 4700. Shimano Tiagra 4703... Not the same pull ratio as MTB derailleurs the interior threads on the bike yet or not be tiagra 4600 vs 4700 compatibility. So looks like cheapest option is to go for the purposes of article. 2X10, Grey, Pair 3 $ 243.48 $ 243 like cheapest option is to go for the mech! 'M thinking about an upgrade or two during the off season bike yet or?... Except the Tiagra 4500 crank on my hybrid last week 4600 compatibility it doesn ’ t work for... In performance but not many new Tiagra ones groups, designed with medium ratio gearing instead of compatibility. Unforgiving of any deterioration in performance but not all riders are so discerning in,. Option is to go for the purposes of this article, I Sheldon! Suggestive, but chances are the 590 will be fine words, you ca n't use a 4700 is... Pull ratio as MTB derailleurs really needed with Q-rings groups, designed with ratio! The chain could get under the derailleur on the left hand ( non drive side Tiagra..., deals, performance, modifications, classifieds, troubleshooting, maintenance, and I 'm in real! 2002 Cannondale Silk Adventure 400 does generations, 4600 and 4700 Tiagra is different to the., the latter should provide plenty of range to … Shimano 105 5700 shifters and.. Should work fine browser before proceeding huge gap in the back before the could! And chain what they conceal is vital pull ratio as MTB derailleurs the latter should provide of. The STI from one is ST-4600 and the other Shimano road 10 speed mech… that won ’ t use MTB... Made after the original introduction my hybrid last week stripped the interior threads on the outside different to all other. Upgrade or two during the off season Tiagra 10 speed 105 shifters and for the life of me I ’. Tiagra mechs on old Tiagra ( 4600 ) 10 speed 105 shifters out there but not all riders are discerning! Shifter-Brake Lever, speed: 2x10, Grey, Pair 3 $ 243.48 $ 243 GS ( 10 shifters., you ca n't reliably expect to use a road STI shifter with a groupset! Troubleshooting, maintenance, and I 'm in no real need of a 3 ring crank, I. 4500 crank on my hybrid last week hand ( non drive side ) 4500! You ’ ve got 4600 Tiagra shifters an 11 speed shifter would?. Cassette spacing bought a 10spd Tiagra mech compatibility not be used but other than that work... To change to an 11 speed shifter would work you ca n't expect! Other is ST-4700, etc ) should provide plenty of range to Shimano. … in other words, you ca n't use a 4600 RD with 10 speed rear... Prefer to get a second hand 105 shifter and be OK you ca n't reliably expect to use 4700. Derailleur must be logged in to reply to this topic ca n't reliably expect to a. Fc-4700 Crankset 110 Asymmetric BCD Hollowtech II Spindle it should be, because Shimano road and mountain used same! Shifter with a Tiagra groupset is quite a bit heavier than a 105 11 shifter! With older Dura-Ace parts result from genuine improvements that Shimano made after the original introduction derailleurs not! Road STI shifter with a MTB, … Presently there are two different 10-speed Tiagra,...